Blog · AI Upskilling

    AI skills divide: why are senior leaders getting more from AI than junior staff?

    · By Day Seven

    Short answer: New research from PA Consulting finds that 70% of senior leaders say AI helps them do things they could not do before, compared with just 38% of entry-level and junior staff. The gap is mostly about judgement, so AI training needs to teach people how to check and improve AI output in their own work, not just how to use the tools.

    What the research found

    On 9 November 2026, PA Consulting published a report based on a survey of 2,000 UK employees. People Management and Consultancy.uk covered it on 12 November. PA is a consultancy that sells AI and transformation work, so it has an interest in the topic, but the findings are worth reading closely.

    According to PA Consulting:

    • Senior leaders use AI more than three times as often each day as entry-level and junior employees, averaging 6.9 uses a day.
    • 70% of senior leaders say AI helps them achieve things they could not have done before, against 38% of entry-level and junior employees.
    • 72% of senior leaders report higher-quality work from AI, against 43% of entry-level and junior employees.
    • 32% of the workforce say they have yet to see meaningful benefits from AI.
    • 60% think AI helps them work faster, but 37% say they then spend as much time reviewing and refining AI output as they would have spent producing the work themselves.
    • 20% feel overly dependent on AI, and 12% say they trust its judgement over their own.

    The report also looked at accountability. 66% of workers believe the person responsible for an output stays accountable, whatever part AI played. But 21% are unsure where accountability lies, 13% feel less responsible for quality when AI has done most of the work, and 26% feel uncomfortable signing off work shaped by AI.

    Kate Spencer, a people and change expert at PA, said: "Organizations cannot assume that faster tasks will automatically lead to better performance, or that employees will develop expertise simply by using AI."

    Why the gap matters

    Many organisations hoped AI would level the playing field. This research suggests the opposite can happen. People who already know what good work looks like can push AI further and spot when it gets things wrong. People earlier in their careers are more likely to accept a generic answer, or to spend the time they saved fixing it.

    There is a longer-term risk too. Junior roles are where people build judgement, by drafting, getting feedback and trying again. If AI does the first draft and nobody explains what made the final version better, that learning gets lost. PA's first recommendation is to rebuild those pathways to expertise, so employees still learn to question AI output and practise judgement.

    The time figures are also a warning for anyone building a business case on hours saved. If more than a third of staff spend the saved time checking and reworking, adoption numbers alone will overstate the return.

    Practical takeaways by role

    L&D leaders: Move beyond tool tours. Build sessions around real tasks for each role, and show side by side what a weak AI draft and a strong finished piece look like. Teach people how to brief the tool, question the answer and improve it. Pair junior staff with experienced colleagues so judgement gets passed on. Our AI upskilling for staff is built around this kind of practical, role-based work.

    HR leaders: Look at who is getting the benefit, not just who is using AI. If junior staff are being left behind, that will show up later in progression and retention. Make it clear who signs off AI-assisted work and what they are signing off. Your employee AI policy is the natural place to set that out, and our AI training for HR teams can help you lead the change.

    IT leaders: Usage reports tell you who opens the tools, not whether the output is any good. Work with L&D to pick a few tasks where quality can be checked. Where errors carry more risk, agree where a human check is required before anything leaves the team.

    Transformation leaders: PA's advice is to measure the business value AI creates rather than adoption rates or frequency of use. Set a baseline for time and quality on a few key tasks before training, then measure again afterwards. Our guide to measuring AI training ROI explains how. Senior teams also need to model good habits, and our executive and leadership AI training covers how leaders can do that.

    A short checklist

    1. Look past usage. Ask staff at each level whether AI is improving their work, not just how often they use it.
    2. Teach judgement. Include checking, questioning and improving AI output in every session.
    3. Show what good looks like. Use real examples from your own organisation.
    4. Clarify sign-off. State who is accountable for AI-assisted work.
    5. Measure quality. Track rework and quality on a few tasks, alongside time saved.

    What this means for your team

    AI will not close skills gaps on its own. Left alone, it tends to help the people who are already strong and can leave newer staff relying on output they cannot judge. Good AI training puts judgement at the centre, so everyone in the team, not just the most senior, can get real value from the tools you already pay for.

    You can read more in our earlier posts on the AI confidence gap between leaders and staff and shadow AI at work, or find out more about our corporate AI training, AI adoption support and AI training in Leeds.

    Talk to us

    If you would like help making sure AI improves the work of everyone in your team, book a free 60-minute discovery call with Qasim.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do senior leaders get more value from AI than junior staff?

    According to PA Consulting's survey of 2,000 UK employees, yes. 70% of senior leaders say AI helps them achieve things they could not have done before, compared with 38% of entry-level and junior employees, and senior leaders use AI more than three times as often each day.

    Why do junior staff get less from AI?

    PA Consulting suggests that people with more expertise and judgement get the most from AI. Commenting in People Management, business psychologist Rob Baker said leaders know what good looks like and can steer the tool, while junior staff often lack those reference points and end up with generic results.

    Does AI actually save staff time?

    Not always. In PA Consulting's survey, 60% of employees said AI helps them work faster, but 37% said they then spend as much time reviewing and refining AI output as they would have spent doing the work themselves.

    Who is accountable for work produced with AI?

    In PA Consulting's survey, 66% of workers said accountability stays with the person responsible for the output, but 21% were unsure and 26% felt uncomfortable signing off work shaped by AI. Organisations should set this out clearly in their AI policy and training.

    How can AI training close the gap between senior and junior staff?

    Train people on their real tasks, teach them how to judge and check AI output, and give them examples of what good work looks like in their role. Measure the quality of the work, not just how often people use AI.

    Related posts